Showing posts with label South African cinema. Show all posts
Showing posts with label South African cinema. Show all posts

Thursday, August 8, 2024

Oscar Predictions for the Middle East and Africa



ALGERIA- “Six Feet Over” Algeria took last year off, although they reportedly did form a committee. I’m not sure what happened. Despite Algeria’s strong anti-colonialist stance, the Algerian Academy tends to prefer films made by Algerian-French rather than homegrown directors….which has always struck me as odd. So, I suspect they’ll pick “Six Feet Over”, a drama about an Algerian university student trying to regularize his immigration status in Lyon. It’s a largely French production but director Karim Bensalah is French and Algerian (and Brazilian!).  In second place, there’s mystery “No Harm Done”, about an actress confronted by a series of murders. It’s directed by Merzak Allouache who repped Algeria way back in 1996. Algeria did have a film at Berlinale Panorama- the grotesquely titled period drama “True Chronicles of the Blida Joinville Psychiatric Hospital in the Last Century, when Dr Frantz Fanon Was Head of the Fifth Ward between 1953 and 1956”….And if it premieres in time, I could see them choosing 16th century period biopic “Sidi Lakhdar Ben Khlouf” about an acclaimed poet. However, they ignored a much bigger period drama last year and poetry always loses something in translation.


BURKINA FASO- “Katanga- The Dance of the Scorpions ” There’s a great article about how Burkina Faso’s Islamic insurgency and recent military coups have affected the country’s status as Africa’s capital of arthouse cinema. Burkina Faso sent the tragically beautiful “Sira” last year (their first submission in over 30 years) which certainly deserved to be among the Final 5 Oscar nominees. This year, director and griot Dani Kouyate has completed his first film in a decade- an African noir version of Shakespeare’s Macbeth. Burkina Faso’s film industry revolves around the bi-annual FESPACO Film Festival which takes place in 2023 and 2025. That’s why local films premiere in odd years so I think “Katanga” is more likely to compete next year…especially since domestic instability has reduced the number of films produced. We’ll see. It would be great to have Burkina Faso as a more regular participant. 

CAMEROON- “Nganu” Cameroon is split into two linguistic areas- a large French-speaking region and a smaller English-speaking region. Since 2020, Cameroon has sent four films by Anglophone directors from the country’s small NorthWest region in the English-speaking part. I suspect they’ll send “Nganu”, which got a Netflix deal, about an abusive husband who joins the army to channel his anger and rage. The director is also from the Northwest and was an actor/producer on one of Cameroon’s previous submissions. Other options include crime drama “Abakwa” (directed by the Assistant Director of another of Cameroon’s previous submissions and who is also a Northwesterner). The director of “Silent Storm” has been picked twice before, but the film looks like it has way too much (standard) English to qualify.


CHAD- Nothing
Chad’s premier international director (and former Minister of Culture) Mahamat-Saleh Haroun has sent three of his films to the Oscars since 2002. He hasn’t made a film since “Lingui” (which was very good!) in 2021. I don’t think they have anything eligible.


CONGO-KINSHASA- “Rising Up At Night” Congo hasn’t sent a film since their Oscar debut in 1997…that’s a longer gap than any country in the world, other than Kuwait. Last year would have been a good year to return since Belgian co-production “Omen” likely would have qualified (Belgium sent it instead). This year, a Congolese director competed in Berlinale Panorama with documentary “Rising Up At Night”, about how persistent blackouts and electricity shortages affect ordinary Congolese. 

CÔTE D’IVOIRE- “Gla” The Ivory Coast sent movies in 2015 and 2020 directed by French-Ivorian director Philippe LaCôte. He doesn’t have any films this year (IMDB says he’s working on his English-language debut with Joseph Gordon Levitt and Shailene Woodley) so they’re unlikely to send anything. For the sake of completion, I’ll predict “Gla”, a French-language horror-drama about a traditional African mask.

\

EGYPT- “Flight 404” Egypt usually sends a film though they’ve missed two of the past ten years. The majority of their films have been “arthouse” dramas, though last year they sent a very well-reviewed commercial comedy. This year, they had two films at Cannes sidebars (docudrama “The Brink of Dreams” and comedy-drama “East of Noon”) and it’s just been announced that they’ll have two more films at Venice sidebars this year (“Seeking Haven for Mr. Rambo” and “Perfumed With Mint”). To these options, I would add two films by previously submitted directors (Hani Khalifa’s “Flight 404” and Abu Bakr Shawky’s “Hajjan” from Toronto 2023) plus “Rat Hole”, a drama that just competed in Moscow. I see the three key contenders as “Flight 104”, “Hajjan” and the upcoming “Seeking Haven for Mr. Rambo”. Ultimately, I think the box-office success and strong critical reviews will boost melodrama “Flight 404”, about a pious Egyptian woman who returns to a past she isn’t proud of when confronted with a financial emergency, to be the Egyptian nominee. “Mr. Rambo”, which will premiere in Venice in September, about a man seeking to protect his dog who has been accused by a neighbor of being vicious, could be picked if it gets good reviews…but it won’t have much time to premiere in Egypt by the September 30 deadline. Camel racing Saudi co-production “Hajjan” should also be a strong contender.

ETHIOPIA- “Doka” Ethiopia sent four films between 2010-2019 and then seemingly gave up. Because of the “five-year rule”, it’s my understanding that Ethiopia will have to reapply to AMPAS if they don’t send a film this year. So, I’m hopeful that they send “Doka” , a new drama about a nurse who saves a child during wartime.


GHANA- “Tejiri”
Ghana only sent a movie to the Oscars once in 2019 and they’re unlikely to send anything this year. Most of their movies are made in English, although they do have the mistaken identity comedy “Kwame Atta”, which is mostly in Akan and thriller “Tejiri” which repped Ghana at the Zanzibar Film Festival…but appears to have premiered on television.

IRAN- TBD I've honestly no idea what they'll send....I'll fill this in later. 


IRAQ- “1988” Iraq sends some of the most interesting submissions year after year and it’s a shame they haven’t been nominated yet (my personal favorite was “Reseba: The Dark Wind”). With the country more stable, they have sent films eight of the past ten years. This year, they are likely to send “1988”, about the Saddam Hussein regime’s chemical weapon attacks against Kurdish civilians at Halabja. Arabic directors have been chosen three of the past four years, so it is fitting that this year’s contenders are all from the Kurdish north. They could also consider “Transient Happiness”, a family drama about an elderly couple that just got a release on Amazon, “Where is Gilgamesh?”, about a museum guard trying to recover a lost artifact, or “Grief”, a social drama. 


ISRAEL- “Pink Lady” In late July, Israel announced the 30 feature films that would compete for the 2024 Ophir Awards, which essentially doubles as a “longlist” for the Israeli submission (I think there were 28 last year). It’s a pretty obscure list- only one, rap musical “The City”, has more than 40 votes on IMDB…18 out of 30 don’t have any. The key to predicting Israel’s submission is to predict the five Best Picture nominees at the Ophirs. This is almost impossible to do with such a poorly known list but my guesses are “Come Closer” (Tribeca), “EID” (Winner, Best Israeli Film, 2024 Jerusalem Film Festival), “Pink Lady” (Nir Bergman, 1-time winner and 5-time nominee in this category), “Reading Lolita in Tehran” (a Persian-language drama directed by Eran Riklis and starring exiled Iranian actresses Golshifteh Farahani and Zar Amir Ebrahimi) and “Under the Shadow of the Sun”. However, this lineup would be unusual since it would focus on three minority (Bedouin, Persian and Ethiopian) communities. So, “Milk”, “Neither Day Nor Night” and “Soda” are almost equally probable Ophir nominees. You can see a full list of 29 of the 30 eligible Israeli films here (one- Dondi Schwartz's "Absolutely Combative" isn't on IMDB yet). As for the winner, I’m stumped….it’s way too early to tell until these films get screened for critics. But for now, I’m predicting “Pink Lady”, an upcoming drama about an ultra-Orthodox family who are being blackmailed over a homosexual affair. Bergman is a consistent director who hasn’t won in two decades, and women directors have been picked three of the past four years…so their luck has to run out eventually. As runner-up, I have Tribeca First Feature “Come Closer”, a semi-autobiographical drama about the grief of a young woman for the sudden death of her brother. “EID”, about an Arab Bedouin family, should finish a strong third. UPDATE: "Pink Lady" didn't make the list but I got two right- "Come Closer" and "Eid"- plus my alternate "Milk". Also on the list of finalists: "Highway 65" (not a surprise) plus "Halisa" and "Girls Like Us". "Come Closer" got the most nominations so that's my new prediction.  All except "Halisa" also got Best Director nominations, so that's probably the most unlikely.


JORDAN- “The Strangers’ Case” There are always confusing nationality cases in this category and this year, that looks likely to affect Jordan. “The Strangers’ Case” is a well-reviewed film focusing on the international refugee crisis, and how events in places like Syria can eventually affect countries on the other side of the world. Reviews are good, the short film it was based on was shortlisted for an Oscar (it didn’t get nominated) and it got a prestigious berth in the “Berlinale Special” section….where it was credited as a wholly Jordanian production. The problem? The writer/director is American. Contrary to popular belief, films with American directors have been allowed to compete in the past (Angelina Jolie, Josh Kim) but it’s always risky because AMPAS is often inconsistent in its decisions. Still, I think “Strangers” will qualify. If not, they could send “Saleem”, possibly Jordan’s first animated film, or “My Sweet Land”, a documentary about Armenia.

KENYA- “The Battle for Laikipia” Kenya has submitted films seven years in a row….That’s the best record of any country in Sub-Saharan Africa….But for the past three years they have selected local films that weren’t known outside Kenya…and that did not do particularly well with critics. Hopefully this year will be different because they have two strong options. Documentary “The Battle for Laikipia” played at the Sundance Film Festival and focuses on race relations and climate change in rural Kenya. The co-directors are a Greek woman (who got an Oscar nomination for Best Documentary Short) and a Kenyan man. Coming-of-age drama “After the Long Rains” is about a young village girl who aspires to be an actress in Europe. The director is Swiss-Kenyan. This will be difficult but I’m picking “Laikipia” because it has one director who was actually born and raised in Kenya.

KUWAIT- “Honeymoonish”  The conservative Gulf kingdom of Kuwait used to submit films in the 1970s but hasn’t sent a film since 1978….46 years ago. Oddly enough, their best option this year is the frothy rom-com “Honeymoonish” , about a newly married couple who realize how incompatible they are while on their honeymoon. It’s the first-ever Netflix movie from Kuwait. 


LEBANON- “Arzé”
Lebanon failed to send a film last year, for the first time since 2012. I found this very surprising…although I just learned that the two films I predicted they would send (“Mother Valley” and “Dirty Difficult Dangerous”) didn’t get a domestic release until 2024. So maybe that’s why? Both appear to be eligible this year. Two other films- “Arzé” and “Valley of Exile”-  will probably help coax Lebanon back to the competition.  It will be difficult to choose between these four but I expect the feminist “Mother Valley” may be too French and “Dirty”, about the relationship between two migrants from Syria and Ethiopia, may not be considered “Lebanese enough”. “Arzé” (Tribeca) about a family confronted by a stolen bicycle, probably has the edge over Syrian refugee drama “Valley of Exile”…although the fact that the latter film was filmed in a refugee camp may tug at Lebanese heartstrings. It will be close!

LESOTHO- Nothing The tiny Kingdom of Lesotho submitted festival darling “This Is a Burial, Not a Resurrection” during the pandemic in 2020….but they haven’t produced any feature films since. We’ll probably have to wait until director Lemohang Jeremiah Mosese makes his next movie to see Lesotho back.

MALAWI- “16 Barz: King of Bawo” Malawi has sent dramas twice since 2018. This year, they could coming-of-age musical “16 Barz: King of Bawo”, which has the same screenwriter of their last submission.


MAURITANIA- “Black Tea” 
Mauritania submitted the brilliant “Timbuktu” as their first-ever Oscar submission way back in 2014….and it got a well-deserved Oscar nomination. Director Abderrahmane Sissako took ten years to make his next movie…and “Black Tea” finally came out in 2024 after years of production delays. The film- about Africans in China- premiered at Berlinale but it has not gotten great reviews so it’s unclear if Mauritania will take the time to send it or not. I think it looks quite interesting.  

MOROCCO- “Hounds” For the second year in a row, I’m predicting father-son thriller and 2023 Cannes Un Certain Regard Jury Prize winner “Hounds”, which premiered in Morocco in January 2024. Another movie about Moroccan criminals from Cannes 2023- “Deserts”- is also eligible this year. “Deserts” is a lighter film by a previous submitted director but reviews for “Hounds” are better. Both got competition berths at the Marrakech International Film Festival, alongside last year’s submission “Mother of All Lies”. Also possible: coming-of-age drama “Fez Summer ‘55” and Moroccan Film Festival winner “My Father Is Not Dead”. Other options seem unlikely- sci-fi drama “Animalia” and fever-dream “Birdland” aren’t universally liked, and “Moroccan Badass Girl” and “Coup de tampon” don’t seem serious enough…As one final note, Morocco never fails to send a Nabyl Ayouch movie but his latest Cannes drama “Everybody Loves Touda” is scheduled to screen in Moroccan cinemas at the end of the year….though they could technically arrange a qualifying release.

MOZAMBIQUE- “The Nights Still Smell of Gunpowder” Mozambique sent a film in 2017 and they are still the only Portuguese-speaking country in Africa to do so. This year, they actually have two interesting contenders that could be their second entry. Documentary “The Nights Still Smell of Gunpowder” screened at Berlinale Forum this year. It’s about one family’s memories of Mozambique’s brutal 15-year civil war. Arthouse drama “Hidden Era” played at the Tribeca Film Festival, and is about a local artist trying to provide for his family in the capital, Maputo. I’d love Mozambique to enter. I’d give “Nights” the edge because the director is Mozambican, while “Hidden Era” is directed by a Berlin-based Colombian. (though Mozambique’s first submission was directed by a Brazilian!).

NAMIBIA- “Lukas” Namibia sent a film to the Oscars for the first time last year with the surreal Lynchian mystery “Under the Hanging Tree” which I really liked…though I couldn’t really articulate  why. This year, they’re likely to submit “Lukas”, directed by a Frenchman who has lived in Namibia for over 25 years. It’s a drama in Afrikaans about a kid living on the streets of Windhoek, the capital. Director Philippe Talavera is probably most famous for directing Namibia’s first LGBT film a few years back.

NIGER- “2G” Niger sent a film just once in 2018. I don’t think they have anything eligible but documentary “2G”, made by an Algerian-Swiss director in Niger, follows the lives of four human smugglers and their lives in the barren Sahara Desert.

NIGERIA- “Freedom Way” Nigeria, home to Africa’s largest (though not best) film industry, has sent three films to the Oscars since 2019. After the disqualification of “Lionheart”, AMPAS decided that films can be sent in Pidgin English (which is ironic because “Lionheart” was in standard English so it seems like it wouldn’t have qualified anyway). Since then, Cameroon and Nigeria have benefited from this new rule…but it’s still a gray area. This year, “Freedom Way”, a new arthouse drama emulating “Crash”, will premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival, but I’m not confident it will meet the language requirements as it’s advertised as being in English…but it’s still Nigeria’s best chance. If it’s not eligible, I predict they’ll send “Lakatabu (The Monster)”, a crime thriller mixed with supernatural mysticism in Yoruba…it’s much more in the traditional Nollywood mold. It’s also possible they’ll vote not to send anything (like in 2021 and 2022) …but there’s also Ibo-language Netflix funeral drama “Afamefuna” and Yoruba-language wedding comedy “Ajosepo”.

PALESTINE- “No Other Land” With no end in sight to the war in Palestine, the Palestinian Academy (which I understand is affiliated with the Palestinian Ministry of Culture) is going to look for a film that will rally support to the Palestinian cause…so documentaries will have the advantage. The obvious choice would be “No Other Land” (Berlin), in which a collective of Palestinian and Israeli filmmakers work together to highlight military atrocities in the West Bank. It has very good reviews and shows interethnic cooperation. Another doc, “From Ground Zero” features a compilation of 22 amateur short films shot in Gaza during this year’s conflict. It would also check this box. I personally prefer fiction features and Palestine has two great ones- “To A Land Unknown” (Cannes), about two Palestinian refugees in Greece, and “The Teacher” (Toronto), by Oscar-nominated Palestinian-British director Farah Nabulsi. If selected, “The Teacher” will have AMPAS getting out the stopwatch because it’s roughly half in English. Dark horse: doc “Life is Beautiful”, about a Palestinian filmmaker who goes away on a one-month work trip only to find he’s unable to return to Gaza for seven years after the borders are closed.  

SAUDI ARABIA- “Norah” Saudi Arabia only legalized cinemas in 2018 but they’ve now sent five films in a row.  They’ve sent a diverse group of seven quirky films, including a bold romantic comedy, a supernatural folk tale,  a feminist political drama, and a Saudi “Wolf of Wall Street”. This would have been unthinkable just a decade ago and I really love watching the Saudi submissions. This year, they have three main contenders- “Hajjan” and “Night Courier” (both from Toronto 2023) and “Norah”, the first Saudi Arabian film to premiere in Cannes Un Certain Regard, where it won a Special Mention. The Saudi Academy has mostly chosen popular commercial films in the last few years, which bodes well for dark, alcohol-fueled comedy “Night Courier”, about Saudi Arabia’s new underground nightlife. But the Cannes label will help “Norah”, about the life of a young woman living in a small  community prior to liberalizing reforms. “Hajjan”, a traditional coming-of-age tale set in the Wadi Rum desert, will likely come in third since it doesn’t have a Saudi director. This is a tough call…both frontrunners are feature debuts that are said to be flawed but very promising. I can’t wait to see both but I’m predicting “Norah”. Possible spoiler: upcoming drama “Hobal”.

SENEGAL- “Dahomey” Senegal has become a regular participant in this category, sending five films in the seven years since they made their Oscar debut, This looks like a fierce two-way race between two previously submitted directors who premiered their films at Berlinale- Mati Diop’s “Dahomey” and Mamadou Dia’s “Demba”. Documentary “Dahomey” won the Golden Bear and Mati Diop was shortlisted for her (overrated) African ghost story “Atlantics”….all but assuring her selection. “Dahomey” follows the repatriation of a number of cultural artifacts from France to Benin.  I actually think drama “Demba”, about a retired Senegalese civil servant dealing with grief and depression would actually do better with AMPAS…but that Golden Bear will make this an uphill battle. It’s only hope is that “Dahomey” doesn’t get a domestic release in Senegal in time.

SOMALIA- “The Village Next to Paradise” Somalia sent a film to the Oscars once in 2021, with the excellent “Gravedigger’s Wife”. This year, they had “The Village Next to Paradise” in the Un Certain Regard section of Cannes. It’s a slice-of-life drama set in a Somalian village made by a first-time Somalian director based in Austria, and it would be a great way to highlight the country’s nascent cinema.

SOUTH AFRICA- “Carissa” No longer a strong contender in this category, South Africa is often handicapped by the fact that its best films are made in English. Last year they sent a documentary about Zulu music and the year before they didn’t send anything at all (for the first time since 2007). This year saw a slight uptick in the number of films in local languages….but most of them don’t have release dates, putting their eligibility at risk. The most prestigious possibility is the Afrikaans-language “Carissa”, about a woman who gets a job with a company that she learns is going to dispossess her family’s ancestral land. It’s due to premiere at Venice Horizons in September and is one of the films without a domestic release date. Among the other possibilities are a trio of films that premiered at the 2024 Durban International Film Festival- comedy-thriller “Sierra’s Gold” (in Afrikaans, English and Zulu), comedy “Month End” (in Tswana), and crime drama “Sonti” (in Sotho).  Of these, the low-budget “Sonti” looks like the gritty sort of film that South Africa usually sends. Less likely: crime drama “Inkabi” (in Zulu) and sports drama “Queenstown Kings” (in Xhosa) look like they premiered on Netflix which is no longer allowed post-pandemic.

SUDAN- Nothing  Last year’s “Goodbye Julia” would probably have been my Oscar winner. The fact that it wasn’t even shortlisted shows how unfair the system is. Sudan is in the middle of a brutal civil war and as far as I know, there are no eligible films this year.

SYRIA- “Under the Sky of Damascus” A selection committee in exile, allied to the national opposition, submitted a documentary to the Oscars once in 2017. They haven’t sent anything since but – if they did – it would probably be feminist documentary “Under the Sky of Damascus” which seeks to expose domestic violence and misogyny in the country. It played at Berlinale 2023.

TANZANIA- “EONII” In 2022, Tanzania submitted a film for the first time in over twenty years, with great fanfare, but then they skipped last year. They have a few options, including EONII, the country’s first-ever sci-fi movie and one that won Best Tanzanian Feature at the 2023 Zanzibar International Film Festival. They could also consider “The Empty Grave” (Berlin), a documentary and German co-production which looks at atrocities committed under colonial rule.  Less likely: “Muhali”, a drama about Zanzibari cultural traditions. We may have a better idea when ZIFF 2024 announces its winners on August 4.


TUNISIA- “Who Do I Belong To?”
Tunisia appears to have an easy decision since Tunisian-Canadian director and Oscar Short Film nominee Meryam Joobeur made her feature debut in the Main Competition of the Berlin Film Festival with “Who Do I Belong To?”, an expansion of her Oscar-nominated Short Film “Brotherhood”. It’s about a jihadist returnee from Syria- a subject that Tunisia has often featured in its submissions. If that doesn’t get a Tunisian release, it’s likely to be “The Needle”, about a family disrupted by the birth of an intersex child, or possibly “Behind the Mountains”. Unlikely: Tunisia has three new films at Locarno (“Agora” and “Red Path”) and Venice (“Aicha”)…. but Tunisian films usually take a long time to reach cinemas…expect them to be considered next year.  

TURKEY- “Dormitory” Turkey (Türkiye) has sent three films by Nuri Bilge Ceylan and two by Semih Kaplanoğlu in the past ten years. Since neither has a film in the running this year, it’s a wide open race in Turkey. The other five years, they sent three small arthouse dramas and two commercial movies with cute kids. The Turks have a huge film industry but I’m hearing the frontrunner is the 3-hour melodrama “Life” about a conservative father on the hunt for his daughter fleeing a marriage he arranged. That’s definitely very possible, but I’m predicting “Dormitory”, a coming-of-age drama about a boy sent against his will to an Islamic school by his newly converted father. However, I’m hearing that may be a controversial choice for some reason…Also possible: “Not What You Think”, about three siblings who meet after the death of their father, “Hesitation Wound” (Venice Horizons), about a murder investigation, “The Reeds” (Toronto), about a village dominated by local gangs, and “Sayara”, about a Turkmen immigrant investigating the murder of her sister. Less likely: rock biography “Tears of Cem Karaca” and Ottoman horror-drama “Cadi”, which both have good reviews but are probably a little too commercial for the Turkish Academy.

UGANDA- “Lions of Buganda” Uganda submitted for the first time in 2022 with the low-budget but very entertaining “Tembele”. Recently there has been a growing trend to make movies in indigenous African languages rather than English, including Luganda and Swahili. At this year’s film awards, 3 of the 5 Best Picture nominees were in African languages. The two big winners were “Makula” which won four awards, including Best Picture and Best Director, and “Lions of Buganda” which won three awards, including Best Indigenous Language Film. Ironically “Makula” beat “Lions” for Best Picture while “Lions” beat “Makula” for Best Indigenous Film. Human trafficking melodrama “Makula” has better reviews than “Lions”, but the royal costumes and action scenes look better so that’s my prediction. 

YEMEN- “The First Lecture” Yemen has submitted three excellent films over the years, including last year. This year they have a medium-length film (55 minutes) called “The First Lecture”, about a man wooing a young woman whose sister has cancer. Movies over 40 minutes are eligible so this is probably their only potential submission. An interesting new film- “The Station”- by Oscar-nominated Scottish-Yemeni filmmaker Sara Ishaq could potentially compete for Yemen next year.

Monday, December 2, 2019

2019 Oscar Submissions- The Middle East, Africa & Australia (17 films)


Here are the 17 films from the Middle East, Africa and Australasia.

Unfortunately, I haven’t been able to see very many of the films (only 5).  

FRONT-RUNNERS
1.     ISRAEL- “Incitement”
2.     SENEGAL- “Atlantique”

Though these are the front-runners from Africa and the Middle East, as of now, I’m not confident either of them makes the shortlist. Each one is a potential dark horse for one committee but not the other. Submitting for only the second time , SENEGAL won the Cannes Jury Prize for “Atlantique”, a ghostly drama about a young woman in Dakar where many young people are seeking to illegally live in Europe. She's engaged to a rich man she doesn't like, and in love with a poor man who leaves her to work in Europe illegally. That's when the ghosts show up and set her mattress on fire.....So, Ada is having a bad week. It’s a critical darling but I didn’t like it….and I suspect mainstream audiences won’t either. It’s only hope is an elite committee “save”…But as the top contender from Africa, it is likely they could get that spot again (Senegal presumably got a “save” for Berlinale Jury Prize winner “Félicité”  two years ago) just for the sake of regional diversity and to ward off future angry tweets from Ava DuVernay. The large committee used to be a big fan of ISRAEL (though they haven’t been nominated since 2011) and “Incitement” is supposed to be a very original political thriller, focused on the Israeli terrorist who murdered Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin. Seeking to explain the mental motivations of an evil individual, it could follow in the footsteps of “Downfall”, in this case unapologetic assassin Yigal Amir (who has somehow been allowed to meet a wife and father two children while in an Israeli prison). Not sure how voters will respond to a film that tries to get into the head of a murderer…but it worked for “Paradise Now”. It’s on the bubble.

DARK HORSES:
3.     ALGERIA- “Papicha”
4.     IRAN- “Finding Farideh”
5.     MOROCCO- “Adam”
6.     TUNISIA- “Dear Son”

The three Maghrebian countries have each selected an intimate drama from Cannes about the difficulties of life in the modern Arab world. All deal with controversial issues- feminism, jihadism, teenage pregnancy- and all have gotten mostly positive reviews. However, I doubt any of them will have the gravitas to make it to the next round. “Papicha” from ALGERIA has already achieved a minor miracle by making it to the Oscar competition at all. Algerian authorities banned its release at the very last-minute (after it had already been selected to represent the country) but AMPAS proved unusually flexible and allowed the film to compete anyway. Contrary to the pouty, passive aggressive remarks by Nigeria's Genevieve Nnaji, France-based director Mounia Meddour said that “the Oscar committee showed is good faith and was sensitive to the sincerity of our request and for the freedom of expression.”  “Papicha” is a feminist drama set in the violent 1990s, about a group of university women who decide to put on a fashion show despite a civil war in which an Islamist group was killing random women for failing to wear the veil. An ultra-liberal Algerian friend of mine saw the film and claimed it would indeed touch a nerve in 2019 Algeria, where (peaceful) anti-government protesters have been in the streets for months. To my shock and surprise, he agreed it would be dangerous to show in Algeria right now. I haven’t been able to see it yet but Meddour says Algerians are going to see it in Tunisia. Most reviews praise the “girl power” themes but also say the film has flaws. Variety called it “narratively uneven” but it's definitely gunning for Senegal's African "save". 

TUNISIA has selected “Dear Son”, a film about a devoted married couple who pour all their time, money and energy into their introverted 19-year old son Sami.  When he disappears in the middle of the night leaving his parents a chilling farewell note, the couple’s life falls apart. Produced by the Brothers Dardennes, this is an interesting film that sparked a lot of discussion between my friend and I. But Oscar does not like the Brothers Dardennes. And although this film is better than theirs, the very slow beginning and some of the plot ambiguities are likely to turn off enough American viewers to knock this one out of the running. MOROCCO has the best reviews of the three, but has been seen by far fewer people. This story of a homeless and pregnant runaway from a middle-class home who finds solace with a poor, cantankerous widow is an interesting variation on the once-successful “Kolya” (cranky old person + adorable young person) formula. But probably too small to score here. 

As for IRAN, they made a surprise choice by selecting documentary “Finding Farideh” about a Dutch woman who seeks to find her birth parents who gave her up for adoption in Iran 40 years before, around the time of the Iranian Revolution. Though we can’t rule it out entirely, “Honeyland” from Macedonia is the documentary most likely to be “saved” this year....But "Farideh" is supposed to be a wonderful film that makes you laugh and cry.....and perhaps this will give it a boost in the super competitive Best Documentary Feature category.

MIDDLE OF THE PACK:

7.      PALESTINE- “It Must Be Heaven”
8.      AUSTRALIA- “Buoyancy”
9.      SOUTH AFRICA- “Knuckle City”
10.  SAUDI ARABIA- “The Perfect Candidate”

All four of these films have their fans and three out of four have had multiple successes with Oscar, but I don't think reviews have been kind enough to believe that they really have a chance to advance. But I haven't seen any of them so it's hard to tell. Let's take a look:

AUSTRALIA- Human trafficking drama "Buoyancy" is about a young Cambodian sold into slavery on a Thai fishing vessel. Reviews are good but it's said to be a difficult watch and this sort of hyper-realism/tragedy doesn't always play well ("Lore" didn't managed a shortlist spot, though "The Notebook" did).

PALESTINE- Elia Suleiman is known as the Palestinian Charlie Chaplin and his films are adored by European arthouse critics for their comic look at the difficulties of being Palestinian. "It Must Be Heaven", filmed in France, Canada and the USA, is said to be his most accessible film yet. However, this is not European arthouse....his humor doesn't seem to translate across the Atlantic. I've hated both of the previous films I've seen, and I think his films are likely to go the same way as every Roy Andersson picture- quickly forgotten.

SAUDI ARABIA's feminist "The Perfect Candidate"- about a Saudi woman overcoming the odds to run for local office in the rapidly changing Kingdom- has got to be one of the sentimental favorites. Who wouldn't want to nominate Haifaa al-Mansour, especially after "Wadjda" was snubbed? Unfortunately, critics say "Candidate" isn't quite as good as "Wadjda" and that it's main point of interest is its window in Saudi Arabian life. Still, it's near the top of my list of "2019 Films I Want To See". 


SOUTH AFRICA, tirelessly trying to repeat their "Tsotsi" win, has selected yet another urban drama set in the townships. "Knuckle City" is a grim boxing drama about an aging boxer and South Africa's toxic masculinity culture. No major awards, no buzz, and likely a difficult watch.

VERY UNLIKELY:
11.  LEBANON- “1982”
12.  KENYA- “Subira”
13.  ETHIOPIA- “Running Against the Wind”
14.  GHANA- “Azali”

Let's start with the three obscure African titles. First of all, I'm so happy to see countries like Ethiopia, Kenya and (for the first time!) Ghana competing in this category. I can't wait to see these films. "Subira" from KENYA is a Swahili-language film shot over the course of four years so you really see Subira, a young Muslim woman, grow up on screen. A tomboy who enjoys swimming, Subira is eventually forced by her family to conform to a strict religious upbringing and early marriage. Directed by German helmer Jan Philippe Weyl, ETHIOPIA is represented by "Running Against the Wind", about two brothers who grow up together. One finds success, the other remains in his impoverished village, until they meet up again as adults. The most obscure film on the Oscar list, I can't even find a trailer online. Although they had a committee approved in 2017, GHANA took three years to make their Oscar debut with "Azali", a human trafficking drama about a greedy family that forces their teenage daughter to go work in the capital. She is exploited and forced into prostitution, and desperately tries to find her way back home. All these films are low-budget works of love. I think they will all make a positive impression, but don't have a chance of making the top tier. 

LEBANON is hoping to make it three in a row with "1982", after receiving its first two Oscar nominations ever for "The Insult" and "Capernaum". That's unlikely to happen with "1982" (Toronto), about the lives of ordinary schoolchildren during the First Lebanon War between Israel & Lebanon. Reviews have been okay, but the trailer looks boring and nobody seems terribly impressed by it. 

BETTER LUCK NEXT YEAR:
15.  TURKEY- “Commitment: Asli”
16.  EGYPT- “Poisonous Roses”
17.  NIGERIA- “Lionheart”

So, yes, I know that NIGERIA has been disqualified because they sent an English-language film. And, yes, I know Ava DuVernay is very upset about this, because she doesn’t understand what "non-English dialogue " means. But even if Nigeria hadn’t been disqualified, I would rank “Lionheart” dead last. It’s not a bad film….and it’s certainly not the worst film on the list. But it is a formulaic, lightweight and mostly forgettable sit-com of a movie. And while a pleasant sit-com may be fun to watch, it’s not getting an Oscar. And, yes, it is almost entirely in English and deserved to be disqualified. 

“Commitment: Asli” got a last-minute release to represent TURKEY, and is supposed to be the first film in a “Commenitment” trilogy by arthouse director Semih Kaplanoğlu. Let me explain the plot to you. It’s about a married career woman who hires a young woman to take care of her newborn baby. She gets jealous of the young woman…..and….well….for 2 ½ hours, that’s about it. Of the 42 films I’ve seen, this is the only one where I suspect I fell asleep a few times. For me, it was simply not a very interesting story and it should have been edited into a 30-minute short film. Perhaps someone with parenting experience who enjoys watching a baby monitor will like it . Unlike the overlong “Asli”, the spare 70-minute “Poisonous Roses” from EGYPT is the shortest film in the Foreign Oscar competition. It’s a grim drama about an impoverished family- mother, son and daughter- and their lives in a Cairo slum. The daughter is seemingly obsessed with her brother, who mostly ignores her and dreams of working abroad. It’s interesting “poverty porn”, but it’s confusing and low-budget and won’t have a chance here.

Now the statistics:

Number of countries who have participated in the past
: 31……18 from Africa, 11 from the Middle East plus Australia and New Zealand.

Number of countries participating this year:  17, plus Burkina Faso which unsuccessfully tried to submit an entry.  

Number of debuts: 2- Nigeria (disqualified) and Ghana

Number of countries opting out:  Technically 13….But the only regular contributors to be absent are IRAQ and NEW ZEALAND. Both of them have submitted five of the past six years, so I was very surprised to see them missing. This is especially true for New Zealand, which had seemed very proud of “Vai” an omnibus film of eight South Pacific films made by women. It premiered in a Berlinale sidebar, and is likely the only time people in Hollywood would ever see places like Niue and the Solomon Islands on screen. Almost all the directors are NZ citizens or NZ-based and this was a real missed opportunity by the NZ Film Commission. L

Number I predicted correctly: Only 5- Australia, Kenya, Morocco, Senegal and Tunisia, mostly because many of the countries (like Ethiopia, Lebanon and Turkey) chose last-minute releases that I’d never even heard of.

Already Seen: 5.
These films have been almost impossible to find. I’ve only seen the nominees from Egypt, Nigeria (DQ), Senegal, Tunisia and Turkey.

Film I'm most looking forward to seeing
: Definitely “The Perfect Candidate”, a peek into the life of women in Saudi Arabia.

Number of Female Directors:  7! That’s over 40%! Ravneet Sippy Chadha (Kenya), Mati Diop (Senegal), Haifaa al-Mansour (Saudi Arabia), Mounia Meddour (Algeria), Azadeh Moussavi (Iran), Genevieve Nnaji (Nigeria) and Maryam Touzani (Tunisia)

Oldest and Youngest Directors: Probably 59-year old Elia Suleiman (Palestine) and 29-year old Kourosh Ataee (Iran)

Number of Foreign Languages Represented:  Lots of multi-lingual films here, but it seems that we have 5 in Arabic and one each in Akan, Amharic, Hebrew, Swahili, Turkish, Wolof and Xhosa and (because Nigeria doesn’t want to follow the rules) English. Five are roughly bilingual: Persian/Dutch (Iran), French/Arabic (Algeria), Thai/Khmer (Australia) while Palestine’s odd entry is in a mix of Arabic, English and Spanish.

Number of countries with a realistic chance at making the shortlist: Maybe four? 

Buzziest film:  “Atlantique” from Senegal

Oscar History: Four of these directors have been here before, including South Africa’s Jahmil X.T. Qubeka, one of the few directors in recent history to represent his country two years in a row (“Sew the Winter to My Skin” repped SA last year). The others are Elia Suleiman (“Divine Intervention”, 2003), Semih Kaplanoğlu (“Honey”, 2010) and Haifaa al-Mansour (“Wadjda”, 2013).

Controversies and Changes: Well, everyone is focused on the (totally justified) disqualification of Nigeria’s “Lionheart”. While Genevieve Nnaji and Ava DuVernay have ignorantly complained and made thinly veiled allegations of racism, the fact is that they didn’t read the one rule that has remained unchanged for decades- that films have to be in a language other than English.

More upsetting (but not widely reported) was the failure to accept the first submission from BURKINA FASO in thirty years, the self-declared home of African arthouse cinema. Writer-director Apolline Traore tried unsuccessfully to enter “Desrances”, which followed all the rules but unfortunately Burkina Faso did not have a recognized Oscar selection committee. It’s a shame that Ava duVernay used her celebrity to come to the defense of a ridiculously unqualified Nigerian film, when two other talented female filmmakers of color (Burkina Faso and Afghanistan) whose films met Oscar rules were disqualified on technicalities.
Most Notable Omissions: As mentioned before, the most shocking omission this year is “Vai” from New Zealand. Also absent: “The Burial of Kojo” (Ghana),  “Castle of Dreams” (Iran), “Screwdriver” (Palestine), “Amra and the Second Marriage” (Saudi Arabia), “Moffie” and “The Harvesters” (South Africa), “A Tale of Three Sisters” and “Sibel” (Turkey).

Familiar Faces: The biggest international star is Gael Garcia Bernal (“It Must Be Heaven”) but you’re also likely to recognize Nadine Labaki (“1982”) and Lubna Azabal (“Adam”).

Last year's race:   I saw 12 of the 17 films submitted last year, including my favorite film from last year’s competition- “Beauty and the Dogs” from Tunisia.  Also deserving of a nomination was “10 Days Before the Wedding” from Yemen, whose backstory was as good as the film itself. I also saw Algeria (B-), Egypt (B), Iran (B+), Iraq (B), Israel (A-), Kenya (B+), Lebanon (A-), Malawi (B), New Zealand (D) and Palestine (C).